The year is 2022. You and your significant other are pondering having children and your family physician has told you about a variety of genetic tests available. Read the TIME Magazine article posted on the main Bio Blog on advances in Down Syndrome screening, and then comment on whether and how you and your partner might choose to take advantage of genetic testing.
Posted comments due before class on Monday, Dec. 5th.
i do not think the difficult ethical question is if you should have the genetic tests. to me it seems you would want the tests to know the most possible. the hard ethical question is if you found out you had a fetus with down syndrome or some other disabilities would you keep the baby. i am honestly not sure. one one hand i believe everyone has the right to life but on the other if they are just going to live a life of pain or one requiring constant care is it right to bring them into this world.
ReplyDeleteWith the advances in genetic testing such as the MaterniT21, it’s clear that genetics testing is becoming the norm. If I were pondering having a child, I would definitely take advantage of the variety of different genetics tests available because the results would allow my partner and me to make an informed decision on whether or not to have children. Personally, I do want children, and from what I understand, genetics testing only reveals the chance of having a child with a certain disorder or disability. From the Time article, I also understand that testing/screening during pregnancy is becoming safer and more accurate. However, if I were to figure out that my child was to have Down’s syndrome, I would be at an incredibly tough and conflicting decision. In a way, I feel like the abortion of kids due to unwanted genetic abnormalities is immoral, but at the same time, there is a clear logic to it (suffering, pain, etc.). I just feel like, as the article said, genetics testing adds a new level of complexity to the already heated ethical discussions surrounding pregnancies and abortion.
ReplyDeleteThe Time article revealed how more and more couples are using the screen tests to determine whether their child has down syndrome or not. Even though the screen tests are accurate, the ethical question still comes into play. As a patient mentioned in the article stated, most people get the test done with the expectation that their child-to-be does have down syndrome, 90% would get an abortion. I personally believe every life deserves a chance, unless they are in a condition where they would only be miserable the rest of their life. Children like Penny, and 99% of kids with down syndrome, say they live happy lives. Also, those around them have happier lives. Based off my values, I would probably not get the test done, even though there have been major advances in the field. I would be afraid I may never give the child the chance at life that he/she deserves. Mutations are a part of life, and these tests appear to be a type of eugenics which create ethical ambiguities. Honestly, I'm happy my partner and I will have many years to figure out what we will actually decide.
ReplyDeleteI don’t necessarily think there’s anything wrong with taking the tests to determine if your baby will have Down Syndrome - it’s a question of how you respond to the results. Personally, I don’t think it’s ethical to automatically decide to have an abortion because you discover your child will have Down Syndrome. Your child could turn out to be perfectly fine, just like the child in the article who was playing games with McLaughlin’s children. Even if your child has the potential of being non-verbal, it would still be unethical to have an abortion when there’s the possibility that your child could be perfectly fine. And even if your child was non-verbal, the two families referenced in the article said they would not change anything about their babies - even though their children had deficiencies in certain areas, they were loved by their families as if they were normal. In addition, I think that, as referenced by the article, aborting imperfect babies invites problematic questions such as which diseases are tolerable. If people begin aborting babies with Down Syndrome, that opens the door for couples to begin terminating pregnancies in which their baby could have only a minuscule problem but would otherwise grow up to be a perfectly normal person.
ReplyDelete(The site just deleted my first comment. grrr.)
ReplyDeleteI think it's a very good idea to get the genetic tests. I believe that you should always know everything you can about any given situation in order to handle it properly. If the tests showed that my child had a non-fatal genetic disorder, I would keep him/her. I would definitely like to know before hand because children with disabilities require a great deal more care, and knowing before the child is born would give me more time to prepare and gather the resources required to care for the child. Alternately, if the results pointed to a child with a potentially fatal genetic disorder, and he/she was not expected to live more than a few months, it does not seem worth the money and effort to keep a barely-conscious child on the edge of death for a few months.
As much as I respect the mothers who decide to keep their Down Syndrome children, I think I would abort the baby were I in their situation. For me, it's not a question of getting the test--like one of the parents mentioned in the article, l'm "pro-information" as much as I am "pro-choice." I would hate to be one of the young women for whom their child's disorder is a complete surprise, because it seems unfair to the parents (and to their son or daughter) to be so unprepared.
ReplyDeleteThe main reasons I would abort the child are a) because I don't want to ever have to resent him or her for something not his or her fault and b) I plan on having more than one child. Before you condemn me for not wanting to "enrich my life," know that my parents have been close to a family with a son with Down's since I was little and that I've had the chance to see him grow up. He's an incredibly sweet kid, with a great sense of humor and tons of energy, but there's no question that he's a handful. His older brother (who does not suffer from Down's) is very supportive, but I really wonder how much his life has been changed by his sibling's condition. Honestly, as much as I see myself as the nurturing type, I don't think I'd have the patience to handle such a responsibility every day of my life. Moreover, should I be able to have two or more kids, I would hate to see them spend their childhood caring for their brother or sister without the adult understanding of the "happiness" it will bring to their lives.
I don't consider such a decision to be "eugenics" in any sense of the word. I'm glad that my future partner and I will have the chance to make this choice.
I believe that the most relevant point addressed in the article is that on what makes life meaningful. Rochman expresses the perception that it's not the ability to solve a quadratic function that gives life meaning, rather, it's the ability to exhibit emotional attachment and love to another that gives ones life meaning. Thus, the character or moral integrity of a child with downs syndrome is no different from a healthy baby--the doctor's diagnosis is simply a measure of your potential child's level of intellect and physical and verbal coordination. I believe that being a country largely based on individual choice and freedom makes it so that the ability for women and men alike to choose whether or not to abort their babies is a fundamental right. Although, if I were in this situation, I would not abort the child, as babies with Downs are deserving of the same fullness of life as any other healthy baby. On the legitimacy of genetic testing, I believe likewise that the nature of our society makes it so that genetic testing is a necessary service to parents. It seems as if parents are searching for the idealistic baby and genetic testing is a means in which those parents are either reassured or disenchanted about their anticipations for a potential baby. The genetic test for downs could easily be replaced with one that tests whether your future baby would be a mass murderer or not or a test that predicts whether or not your baby will be physically appealing. The potential for emotional attachment is not undermined by the diagnosis of a disorder that results in slowness of psychological and physical development.
ReplyDeleteI believe that a diagnosis with downs is not in any way a reflection on the level of one's character--a child with downs syndrome has an innate right to life no different from that of the healthiest, most genetically ideal baby. Thus, I would choose to give birth to a baby with downs.
I would definitely get the testing to find out if the child has Down syndrome. I would probably choose the abort the pregnancy. Melanie Perkins McLaughlin said that she almost terminated her pregnancy because she feared what would happen to her marriage and to her other kids if she had the baby with downs. I would also worry about jealously and resentment if I already had children. The older children would probably resent the fact that the child with downs was getting all the attention and then they would probably start resenting their parents too. The whole family would have to make sacrifices for the disabled child and I don’t want to subject my family to always having to do that. I would also worry about a child with Down syndrome as school. Would they have to go to an expensive special needs private school? Thus spending more money on one child than the others. There are lots of sacrifices that the whole family would be forced to make, they wouldn’t make them by choice, and I don’t want to make my family forgo their needs/wants without even having a say in the matter. Even if I didn’t have any children, I think that I would still abort the pregnancy. I would be worried that caring for, and worrying about the child with Down syndrome would take up my whole life.
ReplyDeleteWhile I’m saying now that I would abort the pregnancy, if the situation should arise in the future, I think that it would be really hard to decide to terminate a pregnancy just because the child would be disabled.
I would be completely open to having the genetic testing done so that my partner and I would be able to be more informed. Since it is clear that the test is no longer invasive, I would feel fairly comfortable with my partner getting the testing done. However, as many others have said before me, the harder question is what to do afterward. My personal beliefs are that if the fetus/baby could not live outside the womb than it is okay for an abortion to take place. If I found out that the child my partner and I were to have Down syndrome, I would consider aborting the pregnancy, but I would weigh many other factors. Including but not limited to: my ability to support the child economically, whether or not I had other children without Down syndrome, and the opinion of my partner. For me it would be up to my partner to ultimately decide, and I would probably be okay with whatever my partner were to decide. However in an extenuating circumstance (economic probably) I would probably lean towards aborting the baby. As many others have said before me it would be really hard to decide.
ReplyDeleteI would most definitely take the genetic testing, but I would like to think that no matter what the result, I would choose to keep the baby. I think that the genetic testing is great because it can provide parents with a chance to prepare in advance for having a child with down syndrome, but it should not be used to abort a child that the parents know nothing about, except that it will have down syndrome. I think that having a child with down syndrome would be incredibly trying and extremely hard, but it could also be a very fulfilling experience. But I think the main point is that the parents cant know if they abort the baby just because they know it has down syndrome. That being said, I dont know that I personally would be able to not abort the child. Like I said, I would like to think that I wouldnt, but if I felt I couldnt support the child economically or simply couldnt bear to raise a child with down syndrome than I would have it aborted. However, I feel that every child has a chance to live and that to judge a child before it is born is wrong.
ReplyDeleteI would definitely be open to taking the genetic test to see if the baby has Downs Syndrome; however, I would not abort the baby whether it has the disease or not. I think the test is very useful in that you have time (although not much) to prepare (economically especially) for the baby. Even if I'm not completely prepared economically, I still believe that I would not abort the child. Although the abortion may seem like the rational thing to do, I believe in giving the right of life to every child. It seems very morally wrong to deny that right to a child solely because they have a disease. Although this child with Downs Syndrome may take a lot of my attention, I think if I had other children, they would learn valuable life skills in helping care for this child. I don't think a Downs child would tear a family apart; I even think it may draw the family closer. I think raising the child would be difficult, but would be morally right and highly rewarding.
ReplyDeleteTaking advantage of the genetic test would be a no brainer, however, deciding what to do with the results would be much more difficult. For me, it comes down to whether or not the family has the time and resources to support a high-needs child. If a family could raise a child with Down syndrome, I almost feel like they are obligated to not terminate the pregnancy. But if a family would be so strained by it, then they could abort if they wished to. If my significant other was pregnant with a Down syndrome child, I would let her decide whether to abort or not, but I would advise her to decide based on whether or not she believes our family could successfully raise this child to have a life of equal value to everyone else. Life with Down Syndrome can be very difficult, draining, and depressing for both the child and parents, but it can also be very rewarding. People with Down Syndrome can lead fulfilling lives, and be very inspirational to many people. In the TIME Magazine article, some of the children seemed to be leading relatively normal and happy lives. Taking that away seems immoral, and in some ways is, but I would never argue that any rule should be made that regulates whether or not a family can decide to abort or carry on with any type of pregnancy. Parents should always be able to decide. I personally would find it difficult to raise a child with down syndrome, but I would also say that it is better than having no child at all.
ReplyDeleteIf I were planning to become a mother, I would certainly be willing to undergo genetic testing.
ReplyDeleteIf I were to find out that my child would be diagnosed with Down Syndrome, I'm sure that I would face a lot of fear and anxiety about what could happen. You never plan to raise a child with Down Syndrome, so when given this diagnosis, the ideal family life that you originally shaped in your mind's eye and were in control of suddenly changes. Similarly to the women mentioned in this article, I would be worried about whether my child would be able to fit in and be accepted by other people around us. The last thing I would want is for my child to become someone who is ostracized just because he/she isn't considered 'normal.' On top of this fact, raising a child with Down Syndrome would present a lot of obstacles and responsibilities that I would be scared that my partner and I wouldn't be able to handle. Because of all of this apprehensiveness, I can relate to the women who choose to abort a pregnancy.
But despite all of these fears, I would keep the baby. Genetic testing would provide me with a way to anticipate the things that could happen. My partner and I would have a way to plan (as best as we can) our child's life after he/she is born; as a result, the things I initially felt I had no control over would become more manageable. I would want to value this child's life and give other people the opportunity to do so as well.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading this article, I think I would take advantage of the genetic testing to see if my child has down syndrome. However, no matter the result of the test, I will no doubt still want my child to have a chance at life. As Jacob Canick said, I don't think "search-and-destroy" is the right way to use the genetic testing. Regardless of the result of the test, I would not go for abortion. I think the best way to utilize the testing is to use the knowledge from the result to prepare for the life my child will have. If I know beforehand that my child will have down syndrome, I can prepare and ensure that he/she will have a happy and joyful life despite the disability. The studies said 99% of children with down syndrome were happy, and I believe my child would be able to have a happy life as well.
ReplyDeleteI believe that the existence of genetic testing for down syndrome as an option for expectant parents is very important as the results of the tests give the parents time to prepare for whether or not they can keep the child. I feel that if parents have the resources to take care of the child than they should keep the child. If the parents don't have the resources or are unable to take care of the child, I feel that it would almost be better in the long run to abort the pregnancy because it only makes things worse if parents bring in a child that they can't even take care of. It would be a very difficult choice to terminate the pregnancy but one that would have to be made in order to do what's best for the situation. A child with down syndrome would need a lot of care and attention. If I find out that my child will have down syndrome I would do everything I could to prepare for the child, so that I could keep it. If raising a child with down syndrome was not feasible for me or the child, I would seriously consider aborting it.
ReplyDeleteThat is, if I couldn't give the child the care he or she needs.
Since these tests are becoming more and more reliable, I see no reason why I wouldn't take the test. This would allow my partner and I to ensure that our baby is healthy, and if it isn't, then to prepare ourselves to provide for our child. I understand the difficulties that come with having a child with Down's. The staining affect this child may have on the rest of my family and my partner alone scares me, and makes me consider abortion. But, with my values and principles now, I don't think I would be able to abort a child that tested positive. I think, as long as the child is loved and supported, they will be happy. I would be taking this test to ready myself for whatever child my partner and I are having, not to confirm that they are healthy.
ReplyDeleteI feel that the most intelligent thing to do is to get a test done, and to always bear in mind the slight statistical possibility that the test is incorrect. However, it would not be fair to choose not to have a child merely because of a copying error that is, in fact, the fault of one of the parents. Genetic problems are a fact of life, and, as such, it's inappropriate to make decisions based on knowledge of them. As the article mentions, not all Down Syndrome children are impaired in such a way that they cannot learn how to function in society, and to deprive a child of that chance would be wrong.
ReplyDeleteAssuming I would be in a financially sound position to have a child, yes, of course I would take advantage of genetic testing, if only to have the opportunity to PREPARE for my child's having Down Syndrome. There is no question in my mind about keeping my child regardless of whether s/he has Down Syndrome. I think it is horrible that 4% of parents of children with Down Syndrome regretted keeping their child; even though the article didn't mention much about the actual effects of Down Syndrome, Down Syndrome didn't seem to lower the quality of life to such a serious degree.
ReplyDeleteI would definitely have my wife take the test because it would prepare us for the challenges we may have to deal with. Also, it is becoming very reliable so I see no reason not to. However, I don't know whether or not we would abort the child if they have Down Syndrome. Many people with Down Syndrome lead nice, fulfilling lives, but many don't. I would have to consider if I think we can handle the extra stress. I'm glad that those couples who can't will get the chance to abort, because they won't be able to give their children nice lives. Assuming that me and my wife can handle the extra challenge and provide a nice life for my child, we would have to seriously consider the pros and cons of abortion. Personally, I think I would probably suggest that we abort because I don't want my child to suffer. This testing definitely adds another layer of confusion and complexity to the process that will need to be considered.
ReplyDeleteThis is very interesting article to read because they talk about how parents are becoming more concern with their kids being born with birth defect. These parents are willing to pay about $1500 to test a pregnant women to make sure that their kid grow and develop correctly. What really impacted me the most was when they where say that they would just kill the baby that was diagnosed with disease, "You want a perfect baby, and the easiest thing to do is to eliminate a child that won't fit into that mold," says Theresa Howard. That really impacted me because its pretty much murder and it can relate to abortions because you are killing an unwanted kid. I think that these parents should just keep their kids because they are their blood. And if they were to have a second baby there is a very big chance that it would be sick as well.
ReplyDeleteI see no reason not to take the test. Knowledge is a good thing. I think it would ultimately be my partner's decision because she is the one carrying the baby and it is her body. I think the test itself is a good thing because not every couple is able to support a child with special needs and the test provides the couples with the agency to make that decision. I don't think I could make that decision but I would support my wife's decision regardless of what she chooses. It ultimately is my wife’s decision but I think the test only does good because all it provides is knowledge in a non-invasive and safe way. I think the reliability of the test like less than .5% false positives is something to note too.
ReplyDeleteIf I was a mother, I would want to have the test just so I could emotionally and physically prepare myself for the choice of keeping a child with Down Syndrome. I think the test is a good idea for all women just so they can test the fetus and decide whether or not they have the means of taking care of a baby with Down Syndrome. I think taking the test is a good idea for all women, if we have the scientific technology, I think all women should know in order to prepare themselves. I personally would abort if I did not have the necessary needs to care for a child, especially one with Down Syndrome.
ReplyDeleteI feel like we (my partner and I) would opt to take the test so we could make a decision about our emotional, financial, and othersituational readiness to raise a child with down syndrome. If we can't give the kid everything he/she needs and more to be a happy human and feel loved and cared for, I think we'd abort. If we do feel like we would love this baby and care for it as much as we should, then we would probably have the kid, and it would be good to use this information to get prepared to raise the child most excellently from the get-go.
ReplyDelete